Causation in Meso-History
ثبت نشده
چکیده
1 Goal of paper This paper takes a specific objective: to identify and analyze the methodological and conceptual conditions that are involved in postulating causal relations among meso-historical entities, structures, and processes. What is the nature of the causal relations among structures and entities that make up the social world? What sorts of mechanisms are available to substantiate causal claims such as “population pressure causes technological innovation,” “sharecropping causes technological stagnation in agriculture,” or “limited transport and communication technology causes infeudation of political power”? What are the causal mechanisms through which social practices, ideologies and systems of social belief are transmitted? How are structures and practices instantiated or embodied, and how are they transmitted and maintained? Do causal claims need to be generalizable? How do historians identify and justify causal hypotheses? The general answers I offer flow from a very simple perspective. Social structures and institutions have causal properties and effects that play an important role within historical change (the social causation thesis). They exercise their causal powers through their influence on individual actions, beliefs, values, and choices (the microfoundations thesis). Structures are themselves influenced by individuals, so social causation and agency represent an ongoing iterative process (the agency-structure thesis). And hypotheses concerning social and historical causation can be rigorously formulated, criticized, and defended using a variety of tools: casestudy methodology, comparative study, statistical study, and application of social theory.
منابع مشابه
Roger E . H . CARR , ST AT , IN Coates AND TROTSKY
H. C A R R is best known for his History of Soviet Russia, the first three volumes of w hich have been published by Penguin, bu t he has also w ritten on the philosophy of history. In 1961 he gave the George M acaulay Trevelyan M em orial lectures a t Cam bridge U niversity on the them e What is History? In these lectures C arr placed great stress on the im portance of historical causation. S...
متن کاملمفهوم علیت در پارادایمهای پزشکی
In this article, we aim to discuss one of the essential concepts of medicine. As a rule, such studies attempt to clarify the philosophical principals of medicine, whereby the act of medic can be regulated based on his clear perceptions of the principles of his knowledge. In this article, we will evaluate the concept of causation in medicine from a philosophical point of view and through histor...
متن کاملMaking sense of downward causation in manipulationism: illustrations from cancer research.
Many researchers consider cancer to have molecular causes, namely mutated genes that result in abnormal cell proliferation (e.g. Weinberg 1998). For others, the causes of cancer are to be found not at the molecular level but at the tissue level where carcinogenesis consists of disrupted tissue organization with downward causation effects on cells and cellular components (e.g. Sonnenschein and S...
متن کاملKoch's postulates: An interventionist perspective.
We argue that Koch's postulates are best understood within an interventionist account of causation, in the sense described in Woodward (2003). We show how this treatment helps to resolve interpretive puzzles associated with Koch's work and how it clarifies the different roles the postulates play in providing useful, yet not universal criteria for disease causation. Our paper is an effort at rat...
متن کامل